Which Is Better: Breaking Dawn Book or Movies?

breaking dawn part 2

team edward he just so hot
love the way he smiles

The Books Were The Best

i think the books were the best 'cause it had a lot more emotion in it. They left out all the good scenes and Kristen's acting was horrible like in new moon she was supposed to be so upset and like completely messed up and her heart should be torn in to 2, but it wasn't and i hated the sex scene in Breaking Dawn it was to sophisticated and Edward should like scared to death to try 'cause he is a vampire and he is not i cried while reading New moon but in the movie I was like ahh whatever. they could have done better and RPatz character should have a temper but it doesn't. I loved the books I have read all of them like 10 times and I think they were better than the movies but atleast we got something for all the Twilight fans. Jacob was soooooooo hot. I cant belive they made a movie against twilight called vampires suck check ity out and sure that all twilight fans will be angry.

Twilight Saga

To quote Bella, "I need better words"... to describe the Twilight Books. If you love the books then the Movies will be a disappointment. They can't do all our favorite scenes... the movies would be "Gone with the Wind" length. Although, I personally wouldn't mind that, it would be difficult without bathroom breaks. Seriously, Breaking Dawn, Part 1, in my opinion is the best at following the book. To digress a bit.. I saw Twilight on the Movie channel (before I knew about the books) and knew that it was a hacked up version of something that had to be great. Twilight is my favorite book of the 4, but the movie with its green tint and misplaced scenes and dialogue, was not a good version of the book. They got better as they changed directors. My main gripe about the movies is that they took the "teeth" out of Edward. In the books he has a temper, when it comes to Bella... He threatens Jacob in Eclipse... "You will be walking on three legs"...in Eclipse. But not in the movie..Charlie breaks up the "argument" with RPatz looking fierce and Jacob getting the best lines again. In New Moon, for the "Vote", RPatz stands on the stairs looking sad while KStew tells him to Shut Up. Not in the book, He breaks a 50 inch Plasma TV, while shouting, No,No,NO! then bends Bella over backward, holding her face asking "HAVE YOU LOST YOUR MIND??!!??... I don't know if the screenwriter has a preference for Jacob or if RPatz doesn't know how to be fierce. But it really dilutes Edward in my opinion. Back to Breaking Dawn, it is the best movie by far, of the four. But they left out the "Fido" scene and put in dancing in Rio. Please. I would have loved to see Rosalie get a dog bowl in the back of her head... or the scene where Jacob launches across the table to clinch Rosalie's jaw shut during the delivery. Not in the movie... Rosalie's fierce protectiveness of Bella was watered down too. But Breaking Dawn part one, satisfied me much better than the other three. It left me wanting more.

• I agree

  Anonymous | 01.08.12 12:30:08 AM

  I think your right

  Reply | Report Abuse

  

  Review Rating: 0

  • rosalie and jacobs *** for tat

    Anonymous | 01.16.12 08:14:03 AM

    I agree I would have loved to see Rosalie get a bowl in the back of the head. I would have love to see the bowl that she shaped into a doggie dish.

    Reply | Report Abuse

    

    Review Rating: 0

Books, eh.. Movies

I really favor the books, The actors for the movies are horrible! I cant stress it enough. Both Kristen and Robert show some of their worst acting skills in these movies! Taylor really works hard to make up for them, and it works. Love Taylor. But to be honest, the books are better, all the directors for the movies have done such a poor job with staying with the book. I laughed a lot during BD, they messed up so many things, that were obvious, and even if you didn't read the books it's easy to see some things that are, wrong.. to say the least. My favorite is when Bella uses the cell phone, you can clearly see that she hasn't even "unlocked" the screen to the phone when she puts it up to her ear. But I digress, I think the reason I enjoy the books more, is because of the detail. I can see why some people do not enjoy the series (just based off the movies) and I can honestly say, I don't blame them. I find myself watching the movies for more a comedic relief then anything. Where as I will be stuck for hours in the books.

• the famous bedroom scene

  Anonymous | 01.16.12 08:29:07 AM

  I agree on the bd 1 as a comedic relief that bedroom scene with edward breaking the headboard had everyone in the movie laughing including me, glad to see i'm not along it missed alot of key points, and what was with the werewolf fight where did that come from.

  Reply | Report Abuse

  

  Review Rating: 0

jacob, the book, the movie omg

I just loved the book and the movie. I just wish they would release part 2 ASP. I also wish there was a part 5,6,7,8,9,10,&etc. I just can't get enough of jacob black. I saw the movie twice can hardly wait for the dvd. Thank you summit, meyer, and of course Taylor Lautner.

• Team edward

  Anonymous | 12.28.11 04:25:08 PM

  I think that EDWARD is better than jacob because at least edward is modest.... jacob just flaunts his abs and I think it is really stupid... oh and btw taylor's abs are SO blown on.

  Reply | Report Abuse

  

  Review Rating: 0

Movies <3

The movies are way much BETTER ; It has more performance . The books are boring ! i Think when i seen the movies they where way much better & intense !

• I agree

  Anonymous | 12.28.11 04:28:11 PM

  I totally agree with you.... The books are really good but I definately think that the movies are so much better!! Although they did make breaking dawn much more dramatic than the book.... I love all the movies!

  Reply | Report Abuse

  

  Review Rating: 0

Breaking dawn2

The movie is absolutely fantastic!im a huge fan of twilight.

Movie Scenes

Absolutely love the books and the movies, but I think it takes reading the books to make the movies as good as they are to me. Wish so much that the cake-cutting and garter scenes were in BD; the wedding was so beautiful and speeches in movie were not in the book but I guess they added humor. Would love to have seen Edward "manfully swallowing his bite of cake."

• movie scenes 2

  twilight123 | 12.28.11 04:32:30 PM

  I agree.... another part they left out was when they told Charlie they were getting married.... That made me upset... I really wanted to actually see Charlie's reaction!! But overall they did really well with the movie!

  Reply | Report Abuse

  

  Review Rating: 0

<3 It All (movie,book)

ok i keep reading the book over an over an over,,, i have read it prob ten times an five times just in the past month an half.i loved the movie aswell but i thought it past just like clips an the script was just questions with answers. i did love it no mattre what i just wished it flowed liked the other movies... also there was alot of scenes that they left out an scenes that were totally not even in the book.i just want the movie to come out on video so i can watch it alot to compar more

Book Will Beat the Movies

the moment i have finished reading the book...was also the moment worries flooded the thought, that movie is a subject to meet the highest expectancy of giving justice to meyer's wild imagination.