SIGN UP FOR FAN ALERTS

Be the first to watch new trailers.Get news about the stars you love.Never miss your favorite movie!

Related Fan Alerts

Which Is Better: Breaking Dawn Book or Movies?

Posted 11.16.11 by reelz

Breaking Dawn is very different from the first three novels in the series (Twilight, New Moon, and Eclipse) and saw numerous mixed reviews during its release week. The millions-strong fan base was divided — everyone either loved it or hated it. So what does that mean for the upcoming Breaking Dawn movies? Some fans disappointed by the book are looking for the movies to be better, while those who loved the final book worry the movies won't be quite as good. We asked a loyal fan from each camp to weigh in with her hopes and concerns. Check them out; then leave us a comment with your thoughts.

Read Breaking Dawn Book or Movies? >>

Related Movie News:

Comments

books vs movies
wyndygal | 03.31.12 01:25:12 PM
BOOKS! The books just show more depth then the movies, of course the movies ARE good, but nothing compares them to the books! I do love watching the books come alive and comparing them to eh way I viewed things while reading the book.

Reply | Report Abuse

Review Rating: 0

Books vs movie
armywife8605 | 01.19.12 04:34:40 PM
I think the movies are good, but I love the books they are more graphical then the movie. I only part in which the movies does detail more then the books is the the honeymoon love scene. The book only states she runs at Edward and then wakes up covered in feathers. I will give credit on that note. I am also hoping that the movie will answer allot of those whom read the books question, "What happens between Jacob and Renesmee?" The book ends with Bella putting Renesmee in her bed and then cuts out..So I love the books, but there are some good parts in the movie as well..

Reply | Report Abuse

Review Rating: 0

twilight books
kandi | 12.29.11 09:20:05 PM
I think all the books are way better! I also hope she finishes Edwards version. There is room for her to countinue with this story and I hope she does. Would love to know what happens with Jacob and Nessie.

Reply | Report Abuse

Review Rating: 0

Book
Cleo | 12.21.11 11:31:21 AM
I think that the book was way better. there was to many c hanges in the movie from the book. I think they did not focus on the pregnancy nearly enough and there would have been scenes i would have liked to seen like roslie giving jacob a dog dish with his food. and the scene where jacob left to try to imprint on someone else and that wolf chick going off on bella. the movie could have been way better

Reply | Report Abuse

Review Rating: 0

team jacob
miranda | 12.13.11 01:07:46 PM
i read the book and loved it but i like the movie better i dont know y it seems like its giving more detail then da book did and i read da book like 50 times so i would know. also the movie is not terible it is well done there are sum sad parts but wat movie dont have sad parts in them but anyway i say the movies way better. love, miranda

Reply | Report Abuse

Review Rating: 0

breaking dawn
Anonymous | 11.24.11 11:56:46 AM
i loved the book sooo much! but my friend told me that if you have read the book you will find the movie terrible!

Reply | Report Abuse

Review Rating: 0

excited
julie | 11.18.11 06:11:50 PM
cant wait to see movie

Reply | Report Abuse

Review Rating: 0

Movie
JoJo *Team Edward!:[ | 11.17.11 08:08:11 PM
Today is November 17 at 9:11pm and i am antisipating waiting for the Twilight Saga; Breaking Dawn to begian. I am the worlds #1 Twilight fan and Ive seen the first three movies so many times i could resite every single seen:)!!! Im 100% ready to see the movie that will soon change my life 4-ever so now i will continue to sit in the movie theater with my labtop to up-date my thots everyone wish me luck not to burst into tears:..)
Vampires:[

Reply | Report Abuse

Review Rating: 0

Don't just sit there, join the conversation! No need to register to comment, just let us know what you think. Have fun, but please keep it clean and stay on topic — inappropriate remarks will be removed.

Guest Name (Login / Register): Topic:
Your Comment: