Twilight's Charlie Bewley Talks Breaking Dawn's Birth Scene

mrs.edwardcullen

The movie should be just like the book. I am truly in luv with the saga. I read all four books in a week and can't wait for the final movie gruesome scene n luv scenes included...

• this movie saga has made me feel like a teenage girl again!

  nikki | 10.13.10 05:11:09 PM

  i have watched these movies over and over, and im reading breaking dawn for the 2nd time while i wait. this book is so unlike the other movies! its almost like they grow into different ppl. like they grow up. and after she gives birth jacob is finally out of turmoil which i love! i hate watching him hurt! yet i love bella with edward so im happy to see that whole thing figured out finally. i only hate having breaking dawn broken into 2 movies. i dont see a break where they can split it into 2. its gonna be weird. but u hold onto every single word in this book, so theres no way they can keep anything out of the movie! its going to be the best movie of the whole century! im 34yrs old yet i live in la la land while i watch or read these movies!

  Reply | Report Abuse

  

  Review Rating: 0

With new eyes comes a new D (2D to 3D)

I think that until the point of where Bella becomes a vampire should be done in 2D and from that point on and off and on during the transition it should be in 3D because that is truly when Bella, and us as readers from her perspective, start seeing the world from new eyes.

But I also believe that there should be a couple versions made - aka, PG, PG-13, and R. This book gets explicit, and how hard would it be to make a more "R"ish versions for those who are old enough (though I don't think that ANYONE under 13 should be allowed in that version.

The other issue is that not all theaters will even offer the 3D version, if it goes to that, and the movies transfer wonderfully over to 2D.

Hope that my sense makes sense to others, lol.

• Additions from original author

  Anonymous | 09.23.10 11:41:44 PM

  Sorry about the repeat, but I hit enter too early.
  
  I think that until the point of where Bella becomes a vampire should be done in 2D and from that point on, and off and on during the vamp transition, it should be in 3D because that is truly when Bella, and us as readers from her perspective, start seeing the world from new eyes. Also, in the same spirit, I think that any "muddy human memories" should be done in a slightly darkened and cloudy 2D. It is the best way to merge the technology with the book and make the book come on screen like magic. Remember: None of us knows what to compare a vamps vision to something; that aspect needs to be thought of or it will just seem like they stuck white makeup on Bella's face.
  
  But I also believe that there should be a couple versions made - aka, PG, PG-13, and R. This book gets explicit, and how hard would it be to make a more "R"ish versions for those who are old enough (though I don't think that ANYONE under 13 should be allowed in that version.
  
  The other issue is that not all theaters will even offer the 3D version, if it goes to that, and the movies transfer wonderfully over to 2D.
  
  Hope that my sense makes sense to others, lol.

  Reply | Report Abuse

  

  Review Rating: 0

No 3D

Don't do that whole 3D thing it would be just stupid to have it that way. And I think you should make it as close to the book as possible and go ahead and make it rated R, Parents should watch it first anyhow to see if it appropriate not just stick a kid in a movie, where you the whole first part is about sex scenes and birth of a child and Bella's &edwards relationship in general. Minusing out scenes to benefit a child will just ruin the movie for the MANY ADULT fans.

breaking dawn

try to keep the book as is and a very BIG NO to the 3d stuff. I agree that making the movie PG-13 would be a good idea, grant it most kids have seen worse. It should be up to the parents to decide on if their young ones should see this. Stephenie rocks and I would love to see Midnight Sun completed. So much fun...

Stay True ! No 3D

Some Things Are Made To Be In The 3 And Breaking Dawn Is NOT One Of Them. Putting It In 3D Completely Ruin The Movie And Put A Damper On How Extremely Well The Franchise Is Doing !

• Stay True ! NO 3D

  Shyan | 09.14.10 10:04:37 AM

  I agree twilight should not be in 3d

  Reply | Report Abuse

  

  Review Rating: 0

the whole breaking dawn movie

don't ruin the book by making the movie 3-d. Every other movie is done in 3-d now but do the movie the way it is suppose to done.

• NO 3D

  Anonymous | 09.11.10 02:19:49 AM

  DO NOT MAKE THIS MOVIE IN 3D U WILL KILL THE ENTIRE ENJOYMENT OF THE MOVIE. PLEASE IBEG YOU.

  Reply | Report Abuse

  

  Review Rating: 0

• 3d

  edwardsBella | 09.27.10 06:24:56 PM

  yeah seriously i agree 3D would most likely ruin it.

  Reply | Report Abuse

  

  Review Rating: 0

Breaking Dawn

Do the book, not 3d. Don't bring little kids to the movie they are not interested anyway, leave them with a babysitter and let everyone really interested in the movie watch it without crying and playing. I got called a ***** cause I asked some man to take his screaming kid out of new moon. I paid to see and hear the movie not screaming kids!

scenes in breaking dawn.

Hi all,
They are right that there are alot of us out here that are in love with these characters.
Bella and Edward finally marry, and then have the craziness of a child who is different. How will they feel? Where do they go from here in their relationship?

3D is not attractive, but we must see the transformation of Bella......we've known it was coming and so does she. Stephanie's characters are fabulous and we are finally seeing vampires....not sparkly humans. There should be some fear.

Give the kids the credit.....most have seen worse and if these scenes are done well our imaginations will be enough....just as we imagine great stuff from the words Ms. Meyers has given us.

Renesmee

3d would kill the movie, but making the birth of Renesmee as described b Stephanie may take creativity, i think it would be better suited to have it a pg-13 movie. The way its described in the book is gruesome and to recreate that detail would possibly be inaaporiate to little kids, along with the edward bella sex scenes. :)

Nooooo3D!

Please don't make it 3D...... it will kill the movie...! And YES on making in Rated R...... make it as close to the book as possible.....!

• EVERY DETAIL

  Anonymous | 09.11.10 02:26:26 AM

  Yes.Please keep as much of the book in the movie. Who cares, make the movies 3 hour long. Show it all, when Bella gives birth, When the baby is born, keep everything in there. DO NOT MAKE IT 3D U WILL KILL THE MOVIE. Show the entire love scenes from begining to teh end. From first honeymoon to when she makes love to Edward as a vampire. I wanna see it all. I've read this book twice, and before the movie comes out I will read it again to get the feel of it before I watch the midnight premiere...AND IF POSSIBLE BRING THIS MOVIE SOONER. LIKE SUMMER 2011. DON'T MAKE US WAIT UNTIL NOV 2011. YOUR KILLING ME.....

  Reply | Report Abuse

  

  Review Rating: 0