A campus comedy with a dirty mouth, an innocent heart and a surprisingly wise mind...
—Jeannette Catsoulis New York Times
...one problem: It isn't particularly funny.
—Luke Y. Thompson Village Voice
...an IMDB-sparked revelation...
—Ed Gonzalez Slant Magazine
A strained mixture of crude sexual humor, romance, and coming-out story, it's an overly derivative entry from Regent Releasing, made watchable, albeit marginally, by funny supporting turns from Rachel Dratch and John Goodman.
—Tim Knight Reel
A crude and cheerfully sophomoric teen sex comedy about a college student who pretends to be gay...
—Lou Lumenick New York Post
OK, it's official: I no longer care about 18 year olds. Freshman Orientation is the last hyperkenetic, oversexed, foul-mouthed, gender-bending, college frolic I'll watch. At this point I've simply eaten too much American Pie.
—Don Willmott filmcritic.com
...Ryan Shiraki's crude, gross comedy of campus sexual errors might push boundaries better were it not so painfully unfunny.
—Maitland McDonagh TV Guide