...laughs come cheap and easy.
—James Diers E!
...not without its comic hooks.
—John Anderson Los Angeles Times
...a slapdash, would-be golf comedy that's barely on par with Caddyshack II (1988).
—Tim Knight Reel
The tired racial stereotypes that Caddy inserts into the old Caddyshack-style "slobs vs. snobs" formula should probably make it much more offensive than it is.
—Steven Hyden Onion AV Club
—Ken Fox TV Guide
There?s probably more wit and pointed social commentary in the average four-minute OutKast song than in the entirety of Who?s Your Caddy?...
—Rachel Saltz New York Times
...a fiasco that never met a crass stereotype it didn't milk for lowest-common-denominator laughs.
—Nick Schager Slant Magazine
—Charles Petersen LA Weekly
...isn't so much straight-to-DVD material as free-with-five-cereal-box-tops material.
—Matt Pais Chicago Tribune