...mismarketed would-be rom-com about a self-help guru (Aaron Eckhart) who falls for a Seattle florist (Jennifer Aniston) only gets the equation about half right.
—Luke Y. Thompson E!
She [Aniston] has never looked more luminous, but she's stuck in a film as meaningless and muddled as its title.
—Leah Rozen People
...a well-acted fraud...
—Michael Phillips Chicago Tribune
No authentic emotion of any kind happens in this damp, Seattle-based romance, a fizzle for both stars.
—Lisa Schwarzbaum Entertainment Weekly
I applaud [director] Camp for trying to transcend the standard rom-com with a character-study bent, but poor execution renders Love a misfire.
—Adam Keleman Slant Magazine
...starts as a pleasantly bland character study and ends as the unequivocal worst romantic comedy of the year.
—Jason McKiernan filmcritic.com