- 5
...a harmless, predictable but not-very-funny romp...
—Claudia Puig USA Today
- 5
Mostly it feels like a between-gigs gig, the sort of thing talented actors take to keep working.
—Keith Phipps Onion AV Club
- 5
The movie is so laboriously contrived in every atom of its being that the only interest is in seeing if the characters can avoid the destinies decreed for them by ancient formulas.
—Roger Ebert Chicago Sun-Times
- 5
Yes, You Again. We've met before. The pratfalls, the unlikely coincidences, the matrimonial hijinks, the forced jollity of an Olive Garden commercial are all strikingly familiar in this prefab comedy.
—Keith Staskiewicz Entertainment Weekly
- 5
...dull...
—Alynda Wheat People
- 4
Disney's effort to turn Kristen Bell into America's Sweetheart reaches its tipping point with You Again, a flat romantic comedy that packages her in a funny setup and surrounds her with funny people.
—Roger Moore Chicago Tribune
- 4
...one set piece after another in which the women make fools of themselves as the script herds them toward a happy ending of hugs and tears.
—Ernest Hardy Village Voice
- 4
Sadly, not even Betty White can save this trainwreck.
—Peter Paras E!
- 4
...one set piece after another in which the women make fools of themselves as the script herds them toward a happy ending of hugs and tears.
—Ernest Hardy LA Weekly
- 3
This wedding comedy ... has no inherent laughs, so an extremely versatile and talented cast struggles mightily to make something funny that simply isn't.
—Kirk Honeycutt Hollywood Reporter
- 3
...the movie is scattered and minimally coherent.
—Jesse Hassenger filmcritic.com
- 3
...manages to squander three generations of formidable actresses.
—Andrew Barker Variety
- 2
...a baffling, would-be romantic comedy...
—Glenn Whipp Los Angeles Times
- 2
...doesn't even qualify as half-assed.
—Rob Humanick Slant Magazine
- 1
...exalts shallow, materialistic values, then tries to camouflage its essentially poisonous content with several layers of sugar coating and weepy reconciliation. Once you've consumed its empty calories, expect a sickly aftertaste.
—Stephen Holden New York Times
- 0
...could be taught at film schools as an example of how not to make a movie.
—Lou Lumenick New York Post